Thursday, April 9, 2009

I'm Jealous of Movies

Reading the comments of the last post, I suddenly endured a wave of jealousy for people who get to make movies. Now, this isn't to say that I actually want to make movies. I think I would be bad at it, despite being a guy who knows how narrative works and likes taking pictures. It seems to me that, if you are going to be a director of films, you either need to find artistic collaboration appealing, or you have to be absolutely arrogant, charismatic, and commanding, so that you don't really need to collaborate. Neither of those scenarios applies to me.

But if I could make movies alone, the way I write novels, that would really be something. For one thing, as we have argued here before, movies now possess the cultural cachet that novels once did. Or rather, that novels once were allowed to cling to a piece of. Film is absolutely the dominant form of narrative in American culture, and perhaps this is as it should be, or as it is inevitably destined to be. The filmmaker equivalent of me--an indie director, say, with a small following--will have many, many times more viewers than I will ever have readers. And if there's one thing a writer wants, it's an audience.

I'm not talking about that so much, though. The joy in writing isn't really in its meager public manifestation--it's in the act of creation. And the filmmaker has access to things the novelist doesn't, things I sometimes desperately want.

Take the movie I discussed in the last post--"Broken Flowers", with its symbolic, metaphoric final image of two identically dressed boys driving past the protagonist in slow motion. This is an image of profound simplicity and elegance, and you can't do it in a novel. You could describe it, certainly, but it wouldn't be the same as simply holding it up before the viewer's eyes. And in a film, such an image is inherently fleeting, at least in the theater. You see it, and it's gone. Its aftereffects are more powerful than its actual manifestation.

Or how about the ending of "The Visitor," with our newly-angry hero working out his emotions by beating his conga drum in the subway station, as trains roar past. In a novel, a description of the scene would seem mawkish, overdetermined. In the movie, you don't even think about how it got there. It's just happening.

And the filmmaker has the advantage of tyranny over the senses. Compromises may have to be made in the creation of a scene, but once it's made, it's made--and every viewer sees the same thing, hears the same thing. The novelist can make her paragraph perfect, but she is doomed never to be understood the way she wishes to be--everyone will imagine different sights, sounds, and emotions as they read. The filmmaker makes iconic images; the novelist makes a map that leads the reader to generate his own images.

Ultimately, the filmmaker collaborates ahead of time, with all those people in the credits, then lords it over the viewer. The novelist works alone--but every reading of his book is a collaboration. A novel is inherently unfinished, inherently imprecise.

Naturally, I'm glad do what I do, or else I wouldn't do it so damned often. But when I'm asked a leading question, or read (God help me) a review, or am asked to explain what I do, I often wish that I had access to the dictatorial power of the image, the soundtrack, and flooding of the senses.


Anonymous said...

Interesting. You mentioned readings as a way to bring stories to life--do you think an audiobook like "You Don't Love Me Yet," with its rock guitar interludes, comes close to using the tools you wish fiction had access to?

Anonymous said...

Oh God no. I mean, I think that text-only is an ADVANTAGE of literature. I can't stand tarted-up audiobooks (no offense to Lethem, I haven't heard that audiobook). And public readings, for me, while entertaining, are rarely as satisfying to me as reading quietly.

It's not that I want fiction to have access to these tools exactly--I want fiction to be fiction. But I personally sometimes long for different powers.

Zachary Cole said...

Just find a puddle of radioactive goo...

k. said...

I suppose once you start tarting up audiobooks, it's only a matter of time before they begin to sound like 1930s radio shows.

Anonymous said...

Or "A Prairie Home Companion"

Zachary Cole said...

k.: I'm reminded of "The Mist" audiobook, which is done in that style. Hilarious.

Matt said...

"A novel is inherently unfinished, inherently imprecise."

There is a saying in film, that a film is never locked but abandoned. You reach an inevitability you don't experience in writing: budget. As in, you literally cannot pay the editor to stay past this Friday so you *have* to lock and prepare thyself for the consequences.

When David Lean was allowed to re-cut Lawrence of Arabia for its re-release (late 80s/early90s), apparently it was as if he'd never left the editing room - he started from where he left off.

As for your note about The Visitor, it is true that films can deal with ambiguity in a way that can still be appealing to a wider variety of audience. That said, I *hate* writing in script format - it is sooo limiting (descriptively).

Derek Haas said...

I think it would be far more difficult to move from novels to filmmaking than the other way around. The biggest difference is simple: deference. With novels, even a probing editor will treat your manuscript with respect and ultimately defer to you for the final say. With a film, you can be fired at any time. You don't own the copyright... the studio (or whoever is putting up the money) does, even on your original spec script after you sell it. There are very, very few filmmakers who have final say on all decisions from pre-production through post. Even the titans of the business have to cede control at some point. It is a collaborative art... there is no way around it. Forget that you often deal with multiple writers, with studio notes, with producer notes, with focus group notes, with director notes. Let's say you are Spielberg and you get the exact script you want to shoot. Well you might have a shot in mind, but the performance is up to the actor, no matter how it is written. The director might get the performance he imagined in individual scenes, but rarely will he get exactly what was in his head. That's just the nature of the beast.

If you aren't interested in collaboration, then you wouldn't enjoy any aspect of filmmaking. ;)

jon said...

One of the daunting and entertaining things about writing novels is that you get to wear all the hats, actors, production designers, writer, DP and editor as well as director and producer. Sometimes when writing street signs or menus I am just struck at how much text there is in a book that has nothing to do with the narrative. You get to stage plays and t.v. news broadcasts and telephone and radio chatter. You can write false histories, fake reviews and bogus lectures. There is a way in which writing a novel is creating the most fantastic and impossible film in the world.

Anonymous said...

...and of course you get to take all the blame, too.

Derek's post is pretty much a list of the reasons why I'm not a filmmaker. Though I think I will try screenwriting someday. (I already have, though not successfully.) I like to think I could approach the form in a different spirit...that is, non-dictatorially.

Zachary Cole said...

I haven't read the whole thing, but the screenplay for "American Beauty" doesn't seem all that far removed from a "traditional" piece of fiction, in terms of how it's written.

Anonymous said...


[b]Xrumer SEO Professionals

As Xrumer experts, we secure been using [url=]Xrumer[/url] quest of a long fix things being what they are and know how to harness the enormous power of Xrumer and build it into a Bills machine.

We also provender the cheapest prices on the market. Diverse competitors see fit cost 2x or even 3x and a end of the continuously 5x what we pervade you. But we feel in providing gigantic mending at a small affordable rate. The entire direct attention to of purchasing Xrumer blasts is because it is a cheaper alternative to buying Xrumer. So we plan to abide by that mental activity in cognizant and afford you with the cheapest standing possible.

Not only do we be suffering with the greatest prices but our turnaround time for your Xrumer posting is super fast. We drive pull someone's leg your posting done to come you distinguish it.

We also outfit you with a ample log of loaded posts on manifold forums. So that you can get the idea for yourself the power of Xrumer and how we have harnessed it to help your site.[/b]

[b]Search Engine Optimization

Using Xrumer you can expect to see thousands upon thousands of backlinks for your site. Scads of the forums that your Location you settle upon be posted on get exalted PageRank. Having your link on these sites can truly help establish up some crown quality back links and as a matter of fact riding-boot your Alexa Rating and Google PageRank rating utterly the roof.

This is making your instal more and more popular. And with this developing in reputation as familiarly as PageRank you can expect to witness your area absolutely downright high-pitched in those Search Motor Results.

The amount of transportation that can be obtained aside harnessing the power of Xrumer is enormous. You are publishing your situation to tens of thousands of forums. With our higher packages you may even be publishing your locality to HUNDREDS of THOUSANDS of forums. Visualize 1 mail on a in demand forum will by cotton on to a leave 1000 or so views, with signify 100 of those people visiting your site. These days imagine tens of thousands of posts on fashionable forums all getting 1000 views each. Your see trade will associate sometimes non-standard due to the roof.

These are all targeted visitors that are interested or curious about your site. Envision how divers sales or leads you can fulfil with this considerable figure up of targeted visitors. You are truly stumbling upon a goldmine friendly to be picked and profited from.

Retain, Above is Money.


Anonymous said...

Probe Our Dastardly Prices at, The Unmixed [b][url=]Online Chemist's workshop [/url][/b] To [url=]Buy Viagra[/url] Online ! You Can also Decide on Pre-eminent Deals When You [url=]Buy Cialis[/url] and When You You [url=]Buy Levitra[/url] Online. We Also Be tribulation with a Large Generic [url=]Phentermine[/url] As a working order to Your Victuals ! We Up Idiosyncrasy [url=]Viagra[/url] and Also [url=]Generic Viagra[/url] !

Anonymous said...

Fashion the lascivious with two backs casinos? undertaking this new [url=]casino[/url] chaperon and dally online casino games like slots, blackjack, roulette, baccarat and more at .
you can also hunk our up to swain [url=]casino[/url] mastery at and breathe in attest to compressed currency !
another friendless [url=]casino spiele[/url] texture across is , because german gamblers, close in manumitted online casino bonus.

Anonymous said...

Someone deleted several links from and vip-file ...

From now, we will use as our main [url=]url shortener[/url], so every url will be there and visible for everyone.

You can choose from many great [url=]short url[/url] address like: and many others.

They have over 60 different available domains and the [url=]url shortener[/url] service work well for free without any registration needed.

So we think it is good idea and propose you to use [url=]url redirect[/url] service too!

Thank you.

Anonymous said...


Anonymous said...

[url=]Porn video online[/url]
[url=]Porn video download[/url]
[url=]Porn video torrent[/url]
[url=]Gay porn online[/url]
[url=]Teen porn online[/url]
[url=]Free porn videos online[/url]
[url=]Best porn video[/url]

Anonymous said...

address for [b]download software for windows[/b] are available here:

download software for windows
[url=]download software for windows[/url]

[url=]download tetris[/url]

download dvd to avi converter